Moraes and Bolsonaro’s Illegal Imprisonment 16 Days Ago:
Hey, you who follow political news with that mix of curiosity and concern, have you ever stopped to think about what’s going on with former President Jair Bolsonaro? Sixteen days ago, Justice Alexandre de Moraes of the STF has been holding onto a release request that could change the game. Bolsonaro’s defense cries “illegal detention,” jurists point out flaws in the process, and we’re left trying to figure it out: what’s happening? Let’s break it down together, like a chat between friends, with clear facts and a touch of outrage—because, seriously, this affects us all.
How It All Started: The Context of the Detention
It all began in August 2025, when Moraes ordered Bolsonaro to be placed under house arrest. The reason? Alleged non-compliance with precautionary measures, like avoiding social media and contact with individuals investigated in cases such as the inquiry into a possible “coup” or his son Eduardo Bolsonaro’s actions in the United States. Up to that point, it seemed like just another chapter in political polarization, right?
But things got messy: on September 24, the Attorney General’s Office (PGR) filed a complaint in the case, but Bolsonaro wasn’t included. That’s right—no formal charges against him, so the house arrest lost its legal grounding, according to experts. Two days later, his defense requested the revocation of the detention and restrictions (like an electronic ankle monitor and no visits). And what happened? Nothing. Moraes hasn’t responded, issued a ruling, or sent it to the PGR for review. Sixteen days of silence—and that’s sparking a huge debate.
Why Are They Calling It “Illegal Detention”?
Let’s be straight: no one should be detained without a clear reason, right? The Brazilian Constitution is crystal clear on this. Here are the points making jurists raise their eyebrows:
- No Charges, No Crime: The PGR hasn’t formally accused Bolsonaro, so legally, there’s no basis to keep him under house arrest.
- Lack of Speed: The Criminal Procedure Code requires swift review of release requests, especially in precautionary detention cases. Yet, Moraes is holding it up without explanation.
- Flight Risk? Where’s the Evidence? The Federal Police mentioned a “flight risk” initially, but they haven’t provided concrete proof, like purchased tickets or suspicious movements.
- Suspicion of Politicization: Some analysts, like constitutional lawyer André Marsiglia, suggest the delay might have political motives, such as preventing protests or laying groundwork for harsher decisions later. Transparency International has already flagged judicial rulings with “fragile grounds” that seem aimed at silencing political voices.
The Impact of All This: Why Should You Care?
Think about it: if a former president can be “detained” at home without clear justification, what stops that from happening to any citizen? It’s about your freedom, mine, and everyone’s. When the STF delays rulings or ignores due process, trust in justice wavers.
And it’s not just social media chatter: outlets like Folha de S.Paulo and O Antagonista note that Moraes has faced criticism for delays in other sensitive cases, raising questions of “selectivity.” Plus, there’s the practical side: Bolsonaro is isolated, no phone, no visits (except lawyers), and wearing an ankle monitor. That’s not just punishment—it’s a heavy restriction for someone not yet convicted of anything. CNN Brasil and Agência Brasil confirm the case is stalled at the STF, with no signs of movement.
What Now? What Can You Do?
If this story leaves you with a knot in your stomach, don’t just stay indignant! Here are some ideas to turn that feeling into action:
- Spread the Word: Share this article with friends or your WhatsApp group. Knowledge is power!
- Demand Transparency: Use social media to ask: where’s the STF’s response? Tag journalists or politicians who cover this.
- Learn More: Want to understand how justice works (or should work)? The online course “Justice and Rights in Brazil” from the Direito Simples platform is perfect. It offers practical lessons on how the legal system operates and how to defend your rights.
What Now? What’s the Next Chapter?
The big question is: will Moraes release Bolsonaro or let this saga drag on? Some bet he’s waiting for the “right moment” to avoid a bigger crisis, while others say it’s just another chapter in polarization. What do you think? Share your opinion in the comments—I want to hear from you!
In the meantime, stay tuned to the news and keep demanding justice. After all, in a country like ours, democracy depends on all of us. Take care, and see you next time! 🇧🇷
Sources:
Sources used to describe the legal and political context of Jair Bolsonaro’s detention and STF decisions.